Muskingum volleyball juniors Brooke Fatheree, Erin Dickson, and Maddie McGee were named American Volleyball Coaches Association Division III Honorable Mention All-Americans. The outstanding play of Fatheree, Dickson, and McGee guided the 14th-ranked Muskingum volleyball team to a 27-4 overall record, their best campaign since 1999, and a share of the Ohio Athletic Conference Regular-Season Championship for the first time since 1999. The trio also helped the Muskies clinch their 10th appearance in the NCAA Division III Volleyball Tournament and the team's first NCAA Tournament match triumph since 1999.

Fatheree, a First Team All-OAC honoree, directed the Muskies with a team-best 367 kills on the year, averaging 3.31 kills per set. Fatheree finished second on the team in digs with 428 (3.86 digs per set) and first on the team in points with 416.5 (3.8 points per set). Fatheree is ranked third in the league in kills per set. This season, Fatheree registered her 1,000th career dig, 1,000th career kill, and moved to fifth all-time in career kills with a total of 1,118. Throughout her three years for the Muskies, Fatheree has logged 1,175 digs, 120 total blocks, and 78 service aces. Fatheree was named the OAC Volleyball Player of the Week twice this year. She was also named to the American Volleyball Coaches Association Division III Great Lakes All-Region Team.

Dickson, a First Team All-OAC award winner, guided the Muskies with a team-best 979 assists in 105 sets played, ranking fourth in the conference with 9.32 assists per set. Dickson amassed 84 kills, 220 digs, and 26 total blocks this year. This season, Dickson elevated to fourth all-time in career assists at Muskingum with a total of 2,948 (averaging 9.57 assists per set). Throughout her tenure at Muskingum, Dickson has recorded 267 kills, 58 service aces, and 109 total blocks. Dickson was also named to the American Volleyball Coaches Association Division III Great Lakes All-Region Team.

McGee, a Second-Team All-OAC honoree, finished the year second on the team in kills with 318, ranking seventh in the league with 3.09 kills per set. McGee also tallied 68 digs and locked in 45 total blocks. McGee was named to the American Volleyball Coaches Association Division III Great Lakes All-Region Team.